Tristram Hunt may well opine that a Labour
education secretary would not "ban To Kill Mocking Bird", but judging by his
pre-election announcements Labour would not reverse the academisation programme
either, nor repeal Gove`s unnecessary assessment reforms, nor do anything about
the 60 hour week many of our teachers endure, nor even promise the return of the
Education Maintenance Allowance, the removal of which ended the aspiration of
thousands of would-be sixth formers at a stroke ("We should have been more
radical",09/06/15)
Putting the blame on Miliband for allowing
himself "to be perceived as uninterested in schools` policy" is a little rich
when one remembers Hunt`s own lack of focus on the subject, and instead, his
concentration on introducing teachers` oaths, a new re-licensing scheme,
Performance Related Pay, and the lack of "character and resilience" amongst
state educated pupils. With Gove-like predictability, Hunt wrote in the Guardian
about "the long tail of underachievement", a view based on Pisa tests where
students from a range of nations are given different questions to answer, and
results somehow compared (Labour could abandon GCSEs within a decade, Hunt
reveals,23/04.15). No mention whatsoever was made of the fantastic work and
results being achieved in the state sector, despite constant curriculum and
examination changes.
Did Hunt ever see the need to consult with
experienced teachers before introducing his policy initiatives? Of course, as he
said, the country needs to "make the most of the talents of all our young
people", but how would that be achieved by identifying a small proportion, the
so-called "gifted and talented", and giving them special treatment? (Labour must
do more to cater for gifted children, says Tristram Hunt, 02/02/15) All children
deserve an education system which will stretch them to the limit, so designating
some as worthy of preferential treatment is clearly unfair.
Education, as Hunt says, "must be our vehicle
for a bigger story of Britain", but few will be convinced, especially with this
scapegoating, that he should be driving it! Did he ever commit Labour to a
review of teachers` pay and conditions, or even to meet with teachers` union
leaders? And he has the nerve to criticise Miliband!
No comments:
Post a Comment