Whilst delighted to see Ofsted intends to "use
shorter, more efficient monitoring visits" rather than the longer, more
stressful inspections currently practised, and pleased that the Goves are
sending their child to a state school, I have to admit an element of scepticism
surrounds this "good news".Ofsted claims that the reason for the change is the "greatly
improved quality of state schools", so why haven`t they been trumpeting this
from the rooftops, and challenging the negative perceptions held about state
education by employers, many universities and government ministers? The real
reason is clearly more to do with the forthcoming reports from "two
right-leaning thinktanks", and Ofsted is getting its "retaliation in first"! Its
national director of schools even professes that it is Ofsted rather than the
hard work and dedication of teachers which "has made the difference to the
quality of education in England", a claim which, I suspect, will receive little
or no support in schools` staffrooms.
Sadly, the explanation for the Goves`
decision, in the Guardian, is not quite the endorsement for state education one would hope for
from the wife of the Secretary of State, especially as her article appears to
suggest that no school can be deemed worthy unless it teaches the location of
Cumbria, and the chronological order of British monarchs; even the assertion
that private schools have the "best teachers" cannot be resisted. However, Sarah Vine does, as John Harris says, "pay
tribute to the comprehensive ideal", and let`s face it, state education needs
all the good publicity it can get! The choice may well be partly motivated by
political ambition, as some more cynically disposed observers might think,
but it sets a precedent for others to follow, and for that reason alone, it`s
news worth celebrating.
Yes, I think you're absolutely right in being cynical about the cynic Gove's actions.There's very little in the way of good news in anything he does, at least for public education. And his constant undermining of the teaching profession is absolutely deplorable, not least in his endorsement of the use of unqualified teachers.
ReplyDelete